Excavations


... nothing is more essential to public interest than the preservation of public liberty.

- David Hume



Tuesday, February 15, 2022

‘Bandits’ vs. A Civil Militia: What Protestors and Counter-Protestors in Ottawa can learn from the ‘Great Fear’ of July 1789

Rural unrest in the last weeks of July 1789 in Revolutionary France was fueled by rumours surrounding the King and his court at Versailles.  After the fall off the Bastille – a hated prison and symbol of the Ancien Régime – Louis XVI withdrew troops surrounding Paris, thus bowing to the National Assembly (and popular resistance).  His acquiescence was considered a signal that emboldened the King’s subjects who thought they could act on their own against enemies so considered.  Hungry and suspicious peasants took to burning manor houses, destroying in their wake the feudal registers that recorded tithes and dues owed to local lords.  However, peasants came to believe that aristocrats were uniting forces to attack peasants: it was this ‘Great Fear’ that never actually happened.  It was all rumour, but the result was that even more peasants took up arms to fight those believed serving the aristocracy.  As the following letter reveals, civil militia were eventually organized to counter these marauders and peasant ‘bandits’.

Letter from the Commissioners of the Estates of Dauphine to the Committee of Twelve (July 31, 1789)

Our province has been most violently agitated for the last several days; bourgeois militia have been formed in all the cities, towns, and villages because the fear of bandits has spread everywhere; the watch is carried out with care and all suspicious-looking persons are stopped.

An alliance from the side of the cultivated lands has spread a general terror throughout the province.  On Monday the 2th, a bandit no one knew came to announce to Aoste that the village of Morestel was being attacked and burned; at the same time, other bandits announced to Morestel that the village of Aoste was being looted and burned.  The warning drew closer and closer, and the alarm was rung in all the villages; fear seized every heart and it was rumored that twenty thousand troops entered Dauphiné from the side of Bugey.

A letter written from Monferra to the lord of Voiron, giving him news of the arrival of these supposed twenty thousand men, was carried village to village and on to Grenoble, arriving there at eleven o’clock at night; it was supposed that it was only a couple of bandits chased from around Lyon by the city’s troops, so it was possible to dispel the fright caused by this letter.  But because the same warning had been given in every vicinity, even in St. Marcellin, all the people of the countryside quickly armed themselves with guns, pitchforks, and scythes, and ran to where it had been announced that the troops were to enter.  Several couriers followed one another through the night to bring the same news to Grenoble.

The commission convened very early in the morning; the municipality of Grenoble joined them along with several notables, citizens, to deliberate on the means of defense against this supposed invasion; it was decided that it was necessary to create a state of preparedness and to beg the commander to obtain rifles; Mr. Dufort sadly agreed to allow arms to be placed in the people’s hands; the conditions according to which they promised to return  six thousand guns which caused this abusive project to fail.

Tuesday was calm enough, thanks to the precautions of the village watch, which had sounded the alarm in the night, to announce that it was a false alert.

On Wednesday morning, the courier brought the most deplorable news that he had seen the château of Montferra, whose portal had already been destroyed; the people of the château handed over the wine cellar to the arsonists, who contented themselves with burning a businessman’s house.

A troop of these bandits went to the château of Césarges, which they also wanted to burn; they were stopped by the same means used at Montferra; but they urged suspicion of the villagers of the plain, who were supposed to come to loot the following day; the event itself proved the truth of this advice; Césarges has been looted and stripped with the help of carts; everything was taken, right down to the hinges of the doors; there was money there that did not escape the thieves’ foraging; the inhabitants of the neighboring village were themselves accomplices to the looting, mingling with the bandits; only some papers were saved.

The châteaux of Loras and Belaceuil were pillaged or burned as well; that of M. de Meyrieu was ruined; the furniture was broken or carried away but the fear of setting the village on fire saved the building from flames.

In light of this horrible disorder, the Parlement proposed to the Commission on the 29th to join with it … and to include some deputies from the municipality, to confer together on means to reestablish the public peace.…

Courier followed upon courier throughout the day of Thursday the 30th to bring news of châteaux that had been burned or ruined; the list is immense….

All good citizens hastened to volunteer to stop the disorder.  The committee requested M. de Durfort’s troops; consequently one hundred men of the Swiss regiment set out on the night of 30-31, as well as a similar number of bourgeois militia taken from the grenadiers and chasseurs.  These two companies were considerably augmented by young nobles and by the best bourgeois, who were put in step under the orders of M. de Frimont, who commands the attachment….

Meanwhile, couriers have been dispatched to Vienne, Lyon, and Valence to bring troops of the artillery and to surround the bandits.

The city of Lyon, having taken the same precautions of those of Grenoble, sent two hundred bourgeois militia with troops in pursuit of these incendiary thieves; M. Reynaud, Major of Sonnenberg, in the detachment from Lyon, has just told M. de Durfort that thirteen of these bandits were killed, nineteen taken prisons; they were taken to the prisons of Lyon; the provost conducting their trial there; they will be executed there or a reliable guard of troops will escort them.  A consul of the community and residents of the area have been found among the convicts.[1]

 



[1] Laura Mason and Tracey Rizzo, eds. and trs.The French Revolution: A Document Collection (New York: Houghton Mifflin, 1999), pp. 67, 68. Translated by Laura Mason. 

No comments:

Post a Comment