Thoughts on Canadian Political Culture: Criticisms, Reviews and the Poverty of Parliament
Excavations
... nothing is more essential to public interest than the preservation of public liberty.
- David Hume
Showing posts with label James Moore. Show all posts
Showing posts with label James Moore. Show all posts
Sunday, April 12, 2015
"world class" glibberish
Welcome to British Columbia where we have a "world class" actor aspiring for political leadership, but he's as slippery as the oil in English Bay.
Monday, May 5, 2014
Magna Carta Canada: some preliminary thoughts
Did you know that the Magna Carta is coming to Canada in
2015? Yes, a non-profit organization known
as Magna Carta Canada (not Canada’s Ministry of Heritage) is funding a tour (by
donation!) of the Great Charter across Canada: Ottawa’s Parliament buildings,
Toronto’s Fort York, Winnipeg’s Museum of Human Rights and Alberta’s Legislature
in Edmonton. But not British Columbia.
The Magna Carta, signed June 15, 1215, when King John was
forced by his English Barons, espouses clear notions of constitutional liberty
and the idea that “no one is above the law”. The Great Charter is at the root
of the origins of the English constitution, the Canadian constitution, 51 other
member states of the Commonwealth, and the U.S. Constitution. We are not talking about John Lennon’s tooth
here. And it is a considerable failure of the “Harper government” that the
Great Charter does not travel across more of Canada on the occasion of its 8th
centenary anniversary.
We can blame Harper’s chief lieutenant in B.C., former
“Heritage” Minister, James Moore, who of course is also responsible for
stabbing CBC in the back, commercializing Radio 2, and setting the network up
for a series of massive cutbacks. This
is the same MP who now as Minister of Industry used public funds to pick fights
with the Big Three cellphone companies only to concede defeat because he
realized that he cannot brainwash all Canadians – or find another rival to the
Canadian companies. Quite the legacy.
If so-called parliamentarians such as James Moore and
Stephen Harper truly had the public interest at heart all Canadians would have
a chance to see the Magna Carta. However,
one wonders what kind of spin the government would place on the reception of
the Great Charter if the Ministry of Heritage were directly involved. As we all
know, parliament ain’t what it used to be. Neither is Canada. Cynical political calculation now reigns
supreme, where everyone is considered an enemy (even the Chief Justice of the Supreme
Court). It’s Harper who needs King John's lessons from the Magna Carta, but our beloved
Prime Minister is not only hiding from his responsibility to world heritage, he
is hiding from us.
Friday, April 4, 2014
Canada and remembering the Magna Carta
Did you know that the year 2015 represents the 800th
anniversary of the signing of the Magna Carta by King John, who, by so doing (after
being forced by English barons) acknowledged that the monarchy was under the
law? By raising the question of who sets limits on the authority of the
King, the Magna Carta (or Long Charter) contributed to the rise of parliament.
Unfortunately James Moore, former Minister of Heritage, and
our current Minister of Heritage, whose name escapes me, along with the rest of
Cabinet, as well as, assuredly, the Prime Minister, have focussed their attention
on more recent events to mark. First
there was the recognition of the War of 1812, and since then preparations have long
been under way to remember our boys at Vimy Ridge in 1917, and the First World
War in general.
This emphasis on our military history brings out a certain Roman sense of virility. But what about the medieval history of the “mother
of all Parliaments”? Surely the
Government of Canada should want to celebrate the Westminster model of
parliamentary democracy on such an auspicious occasion. Or are the Conservatives suffering from a
serious case of cognitive dissonance?
At any event, let’s also remember that 2015 is also our election year, and it’s our opportunity to set limits on the authority of our
Thursday, May 30, 2013
On the CBC and Civil Disobedience
Bill C-60 aims to give the “Harper Government” control of collective
bargaining at CBC, Canada’s largest media organization and the nation’s public
broadcaster, thereby undermining journalistic independence, or freedom of the
press, simply put. If the Bill goes through,
then the CBC will no longer be operating at arm’s length from the government. Pravda
readily comes to mind, among other examples.
Here is what the American writer, thinker and abolitionist
Henry David Thoreau (1817-1862) would say to the folks at CBC, and to Canadians
at large:
Must the citizen ever
for a moment, or in the last degree, resign his conscience to the
legislator? Why has every man a
conscience then? I think that we should
be men first, and subjects afterward. It
is not desirable to cultivate a respect for the law, so much as for the
right. The only obligation which I have
a right to assume is to do at any time what I think right. It is truly enough said, that a corporation
has no conscience; but a corporation of conscientious men is a corporation
with a conscience.[1]
[1][1]
Henry David Thoreau, “Civil Disobedience” in Walden and Other Writings, ed. Joseph Wood Krutch (Toronto: Bantam
Books, 1981), p. 86.
Friday, March 30, 2012
James Moore (Stephen Harper) and the CBC
Hon. James Moore
Port Moody-Westwood-Port Coquitlam, B.C.
House of Commons
Ottawa
Port Moody-Westwood-Port Coquitlam, B.C.
House of Commons
Ottawa
I am writing to express my dissent with your government’s decision
to slash the CBC budget by $115 million, a reduction by 10% of its annual
funding. It is clear you have trouble
keeping your word longer than six months after an election. This is reminiscent of Maurice Barrès, the
French novelist and rather right-wing political figure, who explained about a
century ago: “The politician is an acrobat.
He keeps his balance by saying the opposite of what he does.”
The other problem is that Conservative members of Parliament
resemble public persons carrying out private aims. We see this when, in the name of an earlier “economic
stimulus,” $26 million were doled out to a dozen (private) evangelical colleges
and universities. Given their private
interests, our “public” representatives anticipate exoneration from their “public”
responsibilities and their “public” statements, and hence the CBC (where church
and state are not in collusion) becomes victim to spurious calls for fiscal
efficiency.
And do look out for the efficiency you want. By turning it into a primary objective, you
actually end up destroying efficiency, because you callously eliminate the
processes of cooperation and agreement, essential “public” notions. As goes the voter subsidy, so goes the CBC:
they are both vital ingredients to a public life of inclusion, justice and fairness. Our elected, “public” representatives are
busying themselves with the elimination of things “public” (and quite possibly
Canadian) in the name of a market mantra that is supposed to further
competition. As an active Minister of
Disinheritage, you - along with the rest of the “Harper Government” - might get
Canadians running on time (say, until they are 67), but what is an ideology of
market efficiency becomes, in effect, a national deficiency. What was considered effective becomes
patently defective.
As Minister-who-is-supposed-to-know-something-about-heritage
allow me to close with a rebuttal by the Huguenot thinker François Hotman,
writing in 1573, who, in his historic resistance, establishes the idea of a “public”
interest worth defending, including the likes of the CBC: “The royal patrimony,
or domain, furnishes a clear example.
Kings have no right to alienate it except for great and necessary
reasons, and those reasons have to be examined and approved by his council and
by his Courts of Parliament and of Accounts.
This examination is conducted so carefully and with such tenacity and so
much discussion that very few people request alienations of this sort.”
In other words, do you still want to be known as the
Minister of Heritage – or as the ideologue helping to destroy the CBC? Are you actually with the public – or against
it?
Yours sincerely,
Joerge Dyrkton, D.Phil.
Joerge Dyrkton, D.Phil.
[i]
Variations of this letter have previously been published as a Letter to the Editor
of the Coquitlam Now and/or emailed
to MP Moore.
Sunday, January 29, 2012
Puritanism on Culture and the CBC: Max Weber decodes James Moore and Stephen Harper in 1904
Its attitude
[Puritanism] was thus suspicious and
often hostile to the aspects of culture without any religious value. …
Although we cannot
here enter upon a discussion of the influence of Puritanism in all …
directions, we should call attention to the fact that the toleration of
pleasure in cultural goods, which contributed to purely aesthetic or athletic
enjoyment, certainly ran up against one characteristic limitation: they must
not cost anything.[1]
[1]
Max Weber, The Protestant Ethic and the
Spirit of Capitalism, tr. Talcott Parsons (New York: Charles Scribner,
1958), pp. 168, 170. This work first
appeared in German in 1904-05.
Monday, November 14, 2011
Reasons to protect the CBC - the case as put in 1579
Here is a look at the text of Vindiciae, Contra Tyrannos, a French Calvinist work written in 1579 during the period of that nation’s Wars of Religion. It was published pseudonymously, and the authorship is still something of a mystery. The work was translated fully into English from the original Latin and French in 1648 a year before King Charles I lost his head, and it reappeared again in 1689 on the occasion of the Glorious Revolution, when absolutism apparently ended. Generally it can be considered a work of “reform”. The following section asks whether the “king” is the “proprietary lord ... of the public domain”, and it explains why we should keep the modern-day CBC:
So what? Just because someone has made you a shepherd for the sake of the flock, did he hand over that flock to be skinned, sold off piecemeal, driven, and plundered at your pleasure? And because the people has constituted you as duke or judge of some city or region, has it empowered you to alienate, sell, or ruin that city or region? Since the people would be alienated together with the region, did it therefore give you authority in order for you to pull it apart, prostitute it, and to dispose of it to whomsoever you wished? Then again, is the royal dignity a possession, or is it rather a function? If it is a function, what does it have in common with property? But if it is a possession, is it not at least of the type whereby the people – by whom it is handed over – retains the property to itself in perpetuity. And finally, if the patrimony of the fisc – that is, the domain – is truly called the dowry of the commonwealth, and, indeed, a dowry at the piecemeal dismantling and ruination of which the commonwealth itself, the kingdom, and eventually the king himself perish, then by what law will it be licit to alienate that dowry?[1] ...
Consequently, if an owner who is squandering his own resources is consigned to agnates or other relatives by public authority and forced to keep his hands off his own things, it is clearly much more equitable that a curator of the commonwealth who diverts public resources to the public ruin, or who completely overturns them, could be deprived of all administration by those whose concern and office this is, if he failed to desist after a reproof.
It is easily shown that in all legitimate realms the king is not the proprietary lord of the royal patrimony.[2]
Saturday, February 6, 2010
How Stephen Harper met George Orwell in High School
"‘There is a word in Newspeak,’ said Syme, ‘I don’t know whether you know it; duckspeak, to quack like a duck. It is one of those interesting words that have two contradictory meanings. Applied to an opponent, it is abuse, applied to someone you agree with, it is praise.’" (George Orwell, 1984)
Stephen Harper is fond of Orwellian duckspeak, because he is always speaking to his group (which is quite like a gaggle – and often not high in flight). Prorogation is massive duckspeak, because it avoids having to do anything with lips, and it prevents any public feeding; there is just a lot of waddling, here and there. Conservative television ads are full of duckspeak, as they squawk a lot, and they leave droppings on their opponents almost to the point of no return: remember the unfortunate Mr. Dion, and to a lesser extent there is Mr. Ignatieff who flies too high (according to his imagination).
Parliament is about duckspeak (and it can sound that way), but Harper and the Conservative Party have honed it to a fine art. Early in January I wrote my MP James Moore with complaints about prorogation (see my blog entry). I did receive a reply, within a few weeks, but there was no mention of a prorogued Parliament, and quite frankly the letter did not say anything much ... until I came across the word duckspeak. Mr. Moore was sticking to script, according to his group, even though a Minister, and avoiding any accountability to his constituents: duckspeak. I do wonder who actually wrote the letter. If it were Rick Mercer’s guess, the office plants had a say.
Another word comes to mind when considering Stephen Harper: “egological” (a deceased friend of the late Pope John Paul II came up with the term). Forget the environment, save for the office plants, Mr. Harper also puts new meaning the notion of ‘head count.’ I thought we had surpassed the ‘Me’ generation, but can the Prime Minister be a holdover from the age of bellbottoms? No, that would be an Orwellian thought-crime. Think way back, I mean, way back, to the age of the Saints, of never doing any wrong, you know, St. Augustine, St. Ambrose, St. Paul, and so on.
“Saint” is an ostentatious title for most of us, if not all. It can suggest incompatible thinking, or Orwellian doublespeak, as if there were nothing better, supposedly (and everybody else is considered a "sinner"), but that is how Stephen Harper was indoctrinated at Richview Collegiate Institute in Toronto. In other words, Mr. Harper still thinks he is one of the “Saints,” the nickname for his High School (where Church and State unite), and he persists in believing he is the head boy. (Incidentally, Margaret Atwood went to the Harper family's old area of haunt, the Leaside "Lancers"). So Harper has finally figured out a way of overriding the Senate (the teachers); in his own day it would have been by old-fashioned student strike. However, prorogation is a pretentious high school kid’s answer to getting one’s own way. Only he has succeeded in closing down the school because initiation rites may have gotten out of hand. Given that Harper is so egological, it really is like water off an Orwellian duck’s back.
Stephen Harper is fond of Orwellian duckspeak, because he is always speaking to his group (which is quite like a gaggle – and often not high in flight). Prorogation is massive duckspeak, because it avoids having to do anything with lips, and it prevents any public feeding; there is just a lot of waddling, here and there. Conservative television ads are full of duckspeak, as they squawk a lot, and they leave droppings on their opponents almost to the point of no return: remember the unfortunate Mr. Dion, and to a lesser extent there is Mr. Ignatieff who flies too high (according to his imagination).
Parliament is about duckspeak (and it can sound that way), but Harper and the Conservative Party have honed it to a fine art. Early in January I wrote my MP James Moore with complaints about prorogation (see my blog entry). I did receive a reply, within a few weeks, but there was no mention of a prorogued Parliament, and quite frankly the letter did not say anything much ... until I came across the word duckspeak. Mr. Moore was sticking to script, according to his group, even though a Minister, and avoiding any accountability to his constituents: duckspeak. I do wonder who actually wrote the letter. If it were Rick Mercer’s guess, the office plants had a say.
Another word comes to mind when considering Stephen Harper: “egological” (a deceased friend of the late Pope John Paul II came up with the term). Forget the environment, save for the office plants, Mr. Harper also puts new meaning the notion of ‘head count.’ I thought we had surpassed the ‘Me’ generation, but can the Prime Minister be a holdover from the age of bellbottoms? No, that would be an Orwellian thought-crime. Think way back, I mean, way back, to the age of the Saints, of never doing any wrong, you know, St. Augustine, St. Ambrose, St. Paul, and so on.
“Saint” is an ostentatious title for most of us, if not all. It can suggest incompatible thinking, or Orwellian doublespeak, as if there were nothing better, supposedly (and everybody else is considered a "sinner"), but that is how Stephen Harper was indoctrinated at Richview Collegiate Institute in Toronto. In other words, Mr. Harper still thinks he is one of the “Saints,” the nickname for his High School (where Church and State unite), and he persists in believing he is the head boy. (Incidentally, Margaret Atwood went to the Harper family's old area of haunt, the Leaside "Lancers"). So Harper has finally figured out a way of overriding the Senate (the teachers); in his own day it would have been by old-fashioned student strike. However, prorogation is a pretentious high school kid’s answer to getting one’s own way. Only he has succeeded in closing down the school because initiation rites may have gotten out of hand. Given that Harper is so egological, it really is like water off an Orwellian duck’s back.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)