Excavations


... nothing is more essential to public interest than the preservation of public liberty.

- David Hume



Sunday, May 22, 2022

Putin reads a critique of Napoleon – and of history in general - in Tolstoy’s “War and Peace”

At that time there was in France a man of genius – Napoleon.  He conquered everybody everywhere – that is, he killed many people because he was a great genius.   And for some reason he went to kill Africans, and killed them so well and was so cunning and wise that when he returned to France he ordered everybody to obey him, and they all obeyed him.  Having become an Emperor he again went out to kill people in Italy, Austria, and Prussia.  And there too he killed a great many.  In Russia there was an Emperor, Alexander, who decided to restore order in Europe and therefore fought against Napoleon.  In 1807 he suddenly made friends with him, but in 1811 they again quarrelled and again began killing many people.  Napoleon led six hundred thousand men into Russia and captured Moscow; then he suddenly ran away from Moscow, and the Emperor Alexander, helped by the advice of Stein and others, united Europe to arm against the disturber of its peace.  All Napoleon's allies suddenly became his enemies and their forces advanced against the fresh forces he raised.  The Allies defeated Napoleon, entered Paris, forced Napoleon to abdicate, and sent him to the island of Elba, not depriving him of the title of Emperor and showing him respect, though five years before and one year later they all regarded him as an outlaw and brigand.  Then Louis XVIII, who till then had been the laughing-stock both of the French and the Allies, began to reign.  And Napoleon, shedding tears before his Old Guards, renounced the throne and went into exile.  Then the skillful statesmen and diplomatists (especially Talleyrand, who managed to sit down in a particular chair before anyone else and thereby extended the frontiers of France) talked in Vienna, and by these conversations made the nations happy or unhappy.  Suddenly the diplomatists an monarchs nearly quarreled, and were on the point of again ordering their armies to kill one another, but just then Napoleon arrived in France with a battalion, and the French, who had been hating him, immediately submitted to him.  But the Allied monarchs were angry at this and went to fight the French once more.  And they defeated the genius Napoleon and, suddenly recognizing him as a brigand, sent him to the island of St. Helena.  And the exile, separated from the France so dear to his heart, died a lingering death on that great rock and bequeathed his great deeds to posterity. But in Europe a reaction occurred, and the sovereigns once again all began to oppress their subjects.[1]

Tolstoy, War and Peace (1869)



[1] Tolstoy, War and Peace, tr. Louis and Aylmer Maude, ed. Henry Gifford (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1983) pp. 1269, 1270. War and Peace appeared in installments between 1865 and 1869. The above selection can be found in the Second Epilogue.

No comments:

Post a Comment